I made this pumpkin shelf sitter last year and have had it listed on my selling blog, Etsy and eBay and it just hasn't sold. An Etsy customer did request a special order - the pumpkin sans the bats. What I did for her was add homespun for the eyes/nose, mismatched button eyes, a stick for the mouth and larger wire coils at the stem, shown below.
I posted the photo on Face Book and got two more orders!
So I decided to give the first pumpkin with the bats a face lift and removed his old stitched face. I think he looks much better.
He's available on my selling blog.